Uche came from a small African country. We were colleagues. Uche and I
were among twelve executives chosen from eight countries for a ten-day
training camp in Mumbai. It meant a lot to be chosen for such a camp.
It was one of the many ways in which we were prepared for new posts and
greater responsibilities. They said the camp would make us aware of the
cultures and business practices of other countries.
The camp took place at the company's training centre overlooking the
sea. We had already spent seven days there, oblivious to the sweltering
summer heat, the brimming sea, and the gusts outside. The huge glass
windows didn't let in even the slightest sound, and when we looked out,
it was like watching a silent film. High, foaming waves chased the
shore. Clothes fluttered like flags against the strong winds. Rows of
vehicles cruised along the beach. Hundreds of little shops plied on
push carts. People came to run, walk, look and buy. The outside world
seemed to carry on noiselessly.
Uche stayed in a room next to mine. That was one reason he got close to
me. The days were tiring. We listened to eight hours of talk on how to
formulate policy and how some company somewhere had been turned around.
And discussions were a must. Dinner over, we would sit around chatting.
We sometimes strolled along the beach. Uche was the centre of our
entertainment. He sang superbly. He played music on his cassette player
and danced to it. It seemed like he was born with the gift of music and
dance. His dark, strong body, gleaming with good health, would start
swaying the moment music fell on his ear. He pulled out a strand of his
curly hair and showed us how long it was. He sang his country's slave
songs. To show us he knew black magic, he pierced a knife into his palm
and pulled it right through the other side.
After dinner on the eighth day, we were told about the plans for the
last three days. A game would be played to see how we would put into
practice what we had learnt that far.
It was a management game. They would create a virtual business
situation and put our skills to test. We were divided into four groups
of three each. Each group represented an imaginary company. All four
companies had more or less the same number of factories and workers,
the same amount of money in the bank, and the same sort of liabilities.
We had to run the company for three years.
The game began at eight in the morning. An hour equalled a month.
Stocktaking of production, marketing and debt repayment had to be
undertaken at the end of each hour. Each day was a year. The companies
had to announce their income, expenditure, profits and losses at the
end of each year. At the end of the third year, that is on the third
night, the teams had to make presentations on what strategies they had
employed, how these had increased profits, what had not succeeded, and
where they had suffered setbacks.
Sixty pages, which we had to read, told us the rules of the game, what
we could produce, what procedures we had to follow to open new
factories, what products we could sell in which countries, what
technology was available and how much time and money we would need to
develop new technology, how much we would have to pay workers, what
labour problems we might face, which countries were democracies and
which military regimes, what religion the majority practised, and such
other details.
This game was considered very effective to orient executives to conduct
business in the world market. Peter, who had designed it, had come down
from England the previous night. We felt envious when we heard of the
royalty he got each time his game was played. Peter had to ensure that
the game was conducted properly and fairly, and also play the roles of
the banks and the governments. He talked proudly about how the game
would teach us to use our real strengths and help us make up for our
weaknesses; it would also provide us with an opportunity to test our
skills in live situations.... All details, he said, were facts he had
culled from many sources. He said he would review everything at the end
of each month. We got ready to manage our virtual businesses.
The game filled our heads. Armed with those sixty pages, we returned to
our rooms. Uche, Jeff and I were a team. Jeff was of Dutch origin, born
and brought up in England. He had worked as an accountant and risen
from the ranks at a young age. We were delighted that Uche was with us.
We had no time for our usual fun and games that day. We had become
alert to the need to read up and be ready for the contest. We read up
everything individually and then got together and discussed the state
of our company. We discussed the rules. The game had begun to seep into
us. It was half past one when we went to bed.
By morning we had crammed up hundreds of facts as though we were going
to face an exam. They had set up the game in a huge hall. Four tables
stood in four corners, and huge world maps were spread out on them.
Inscribed on them were names of countries. Chips representing companies
assigned to us were placed here and there. Uche was excited when he
spotted his country's name. He pointed it out to us. We were given half
an hour to grasp the details and ask for clarifications.
We calculated production, marketing and transport costs and arrived at
a selling price. Jeff, being an accountant, quickly added, deducted and
evaluated how the price would reflect on profits at the end of the
year. We discussed where we should invest our earnings, and the pros
and cons of taking bank loans as against putting in our own funds.
Everything looked simple, and we anticipated huge profits.
The game began. We had to sell our products at the end of the month. We
were given a list updating us on where a particular product was in
demand. We had to write details of products we wished to sell and their
prices in each country. Only Peter knew the prices quoted by the other
companies. The lowest bidders would get first priority. If they
declined, the offer would go to the next lowest bidders. He would sort
out the slips by product and market, and announce whose tenders had
been accepted.
Our prices turned out too high in the first month and we didn't win
even a single tender. Only a fourth of our production was sold when we
reduced the prices of some products in the second month. Jeff warned us
that we would have no funds left for wages and raw material in two
months if we continued at this rate. Nothing went as we had planned,
all our calculations went awry, and what had appeared simple at first
now seemed tied up in a thousand complex knots.
Each team had its own strategy. As soon as a tender was announced, the
winning team cheered loudly. A keen contest was emerging. By the end of
two months, our situation had improved a bit. We thought of ways to
lower prices, and reworked our logistics so that we could make profits.
We had at our fingertips all information about our factories, though
they were mere chips on the map -- the number of workers, wages to be
paid, production capacity, actual productivity and so on.
We could have employed new technology and opened new factories. That
way, and by not taking into account the initial investment, we could
have produced quite cheaply. We had better production potential in two
of our factories, and we were not producing to capacity. We leafed
through the regulations to see how we could set that right.
We learnt about the labour problems there. If we conceded two demands,
productivity was likely to go up by ten per cent. A machine had become
old and four or five workers were getting injured in accidents every
year. The first demand was that this machine be replaced. This would
cost us a lakh. The second demand was a ten per cent wage hike.
Jeff again added, deducted and multiplied, and ruled out the idea,
saying it wouldn't be profitable. In his view, if we were to spend so
much and increase production, the real profits would start coming in
only in the fourth year. Since we were playing the game only for three
years, he said this expense was unnecessary. He suggested instead that
we start new factories with new technology.
Uche and I thought otherwise. We said it would be a mark of good
administration to solve the problems of the factory. Jeff explained his
calculations all over again to convince us that our decision was not
correct. “Man, never mind,” Uche said.
We didn't have enough money for a new factory. Jeff suggested we take a
bank loan. A rule said we had to pay a certain amount to each worker if
we wanted to close down a factory. We could sell the land once this was
done. Calculating all this, he said we should close down a factory.
“Let's not be hasty. We'll think about it,” we said. Not a word of what
we said could pass muster against his power to peer into the
regulations, weigh everything in rupees and paise, and accurately
predict the extent of profit and loss. Jeff's sword of accounting logic
could cut up everything mercilessly. He would have an answer supported
by reason and statistics to every single idea of ours. When Jeff got up
to fetch tea, Uche sighed, “He is impossible.... He could become the
head of the company one day.”
At this point Peter announced that the market survey was ready. It cost
Rs. 5,000. It was a ten-page report that gave details of each market,
its seasonal ups and downs, what product would be in demand in which
country, and what rules had to be followed to sell them. We too bought
it. Jeff read it comprehensively, gave it to us and got immersed in
some calculation. “We can make profits if we expand our business to
Africa,” he exclaimed enthusiastically, as though he had just
discovered something. “But not right away. We'll wait for two more
months,” he said.
When we got up to go for lunch at the end of six months of business,
the atmosphere had acquired a totally different colour. Wondering
enviously how those who had won tenders could sell at such low prices,
guessing at what the others' strategies could be, planning counter
attacks, getting all worked up, sporting artificial smiles, holding
whispered conversations, competing fiercely, guarding secrets, counting
profits and losses... the mood of the battlefield had set in. During
lunch no one mixed with the others, and the teams talked only among
themselves.
Uche, who stood looking out of the window, seemed distracted. "What’s
up, Uche? Thinking of how we can make more profits?” I said.
“We shouldn't open factories in Africa. We shouldn't get into that market,” he replied.
“Why not?” I asked. I thought he had found a flaw in Jeff’s plan.
“Because it will destroy the people,” he said.
I was stunned. Concerned he had become sentimental after seeing his country on the map, I told him to relax.
“How can you say that? You should know better than Jeff. You, with your
castes, religions and gods, aren’t all that different from us. Each of
our towns lives a different life,” he said.
I couldn't fathom what he was saying. When we sat down for lunch, I said, “I don't understand what you are arguing.”
“I’m not arguing, just stating facts,” he said. He broke the long
silence that ensued and told me many things about himself and his
country.
“We are all still slaves. We have a democracy only in name. A distant
relative of mine had become the president. The present ruler murdered
him and brought in military rule. He put up a show of elections and has
been in power for fifteen years. We are forbidden to use the word
‘president’ to refer to anyone but him. In our country, our company has
a chairman, not a president, as in yours... Our country used to grow a
lot of cocoa at one time. The earlier government had built huge
warehouses for its export. People looked upon them as an impressive
achievement of the previous government, so he destroyed all of them. He
made the people poor. Yet he encouraged their desire to buy. Big
companies from other countries were also involved in this conspiracy.
He ensured that nothing was produced in our country. Even this shirt I
wear has to be made and given to me by someone else. All indigenous
industries are dying for want of technology and government support. We
are still alive because we get some petrol and oil from our land. All
of it belongs to the government. Food distribution is in the
government's hands. They only distribute products of big companies. Our
taste, smell, clothes and the amount of food we eat… everything’s
changing.
“What we eat is getting to be the same in every house. No one
wants variety. They want mass production and marketing. If people have
a choice, will they ever buy those products? We work for them and buy
what they produce. We are becoming just cheap labour. Take my house,
two uncles have lost their jobs and are sitting idle. Their factories
closed down, they were given twenty thousand each, and sent home. One
of them has lost four fingers while working…”
I was bewildered by Uche's talk. I couldn’t have imagined he was
thinking of all this. What images he had evoked as he spoke! The
darkness inside their houses, their empty meal plates, the blank looks
of uncles who had lost their jobs, voices that trembled as they sang,
teeth that parted in affectionate smiles, sleepless eyes, beliefs and
dreams, lifestyles that had changed so much men couldn't even hug their
wives.... Instead of looking at the map merely in accounting terms, as
Jeff was doing, Uche was unravelling hundreds of threads.
I just sat there listening to him. "Come, it's getting late," Jeff said, got up and left.
The game was on again. It had put everyone on a high. "Uche has gone
crazy", Jeff whispered in my ear. We didn't argue with Uche; we decided
not to extend business to Africa for the moment. Each player was at it
as though his intelligence was being challenged.
As the game progressed, we got so familiar with the rules that it
seemed we had known them all our lives. At times we felt the rules were
controlling us.
Our calculations were wrong twice and our stocks started piling up.
When we announced the annual results at the end of the year, we were in
the last position, but we weren’t running under loss. Jeff got worried.
He was the type who always wanted to win.
When we sat down for dinner, he said, “We must think clearly before we
meet. If we do as we have done today, we will always be in the last
position.”
"Go to bed early.... sleep well," he said before he left.
Uche and I sat talking for a long time after that. How many things I told him about my country and myself!
I lost as I spoke about our customs, beliefs, marriage rituals, the
aspirations of my middle class parents, the pride my worker-father felt
on my being in this kind of a job. I told him about Gandhi. I told him
about the freedom we had won in I947 and the politics of the country, I
told him about the anxieties that rob me of my sleep. I told him about
my childhood, I told him about my wife. I described to him colourfully
how some people are possessed, I told him about the taste of patrode.
Embarrassed that I had spoken too much, I went back my room. I couldn't
sleep well. In the morning, Jeff came to my room and told me about the
strategies he had worked out. Uche's words troubled me. The game had
become so haunting that a thought had woken me up suddenly in the
middle of the night. The thought persisted even after I got up, drank
some water and went back to bed. The game had aroused some instinct,
some secret desire, in each of us.
I was distressed by its hold; it tied us down to our groups and
prevented us from mixing with others or enjoying anything. I couldn't
continue reading the book I had left half-read. There was no singing,
dancing, or chatting. No walks or the beach. Only this.
The moment the game began after breakfast, Jeff raised the subject of
going to Africa. Uche said it was out of the question. We felt Uche was
overdoing it. We had no go but to expand our business to Africa. No
team had yet set foot there. If we didn't get there first, there was no
way we could increase our profits. I tried to explain to him from the
details in the report given to us.
“That's it. That's precisely why I say no,” he said again.
“Don't be such a sentimental fool. We have no clue what you have or
don't in your country. All we know is what we see on these pages.
Understand this is just a game," Jeff told him.
Uche wouldn't give in. “Of course it’s a game. Not just now, it's
always been this way. You pull strings just looking at names and
maps... Would you play a game of killing people? If the lives of your
family were at stake, would you move puppets around and say you have
killed so and so?” he said.
Uche’s words were sharp. Jeff tried hard to calm him. “We aren’t losing
any money now. Let's not have bigger profits. We'll manage as we are,”
Uche said, to which Jeff countered, "Which means you would have gone
ahead if we had been under loss... No fun just keeping money... The fun
is in making money.”
Uche’s stubborn arguments continued. We felt Uche was overdoing it.
There was nothing we could do without his consent. The rules were such.
We had to take a unanimous decision. Peter, who represented the
government, would dismiss a proposal if it did not have the consent of
even one of us. We had no way but to somehow convince Uche.
“Stay here,” Jeff said to me and took Uche out. They returned after ten
or fifteen minutes. “Uche will co-operate,” Jeff said. What he had told
him, whether he had threatened him, whether they had fought, I couldn’t
make out. I felt bad when I saw Uche's face. Perhaps I had spoken so
much the previous night to show him that I had understood, and to tell
him that I too was like him. I also wondered at what stage in my life I
had understood and yet turned it all into a game.
I couldn’t make out how Jeff had convinced Uche, what power he had
employed, or what note he had struck. “Yes, yes,” Uche said
indifferently to everything. Finally, at the end of the third day, we
had risen to the second position.